Smile (Jeff the killer X Reader)

chapter 11

"Slenderman has been worrying about you. You haven't returned for two days already."

It was hard to tell which one of the two was talking since they were both wearing masks but you supposed that it was the guy with the white mask who was talking. His blue eyes trailed off to you.

"I see you got involved with a regular girl. Slenderman isn't going to be so happy about that."

"Whaddaya mean 'regular'? She's a bloody killer like me!"

"Really? Well, anyway he told us to bring you back so better come with us now."

"Who does he think I am? I don't need a babysitter, let alone two!" Jeff glared at the masked boys.

"Let's go." Ignoring Jeff's protests, the two made their way towards the main door of your apartment. Seeing that there was no other option, Jeff went up to you and gave you a peck on the forehead.

"I'll be back soon. Love ya." And with that he ran after the two masked men. You heard them exit through the door, followed by complete silence, but his words were stuck in your head.

"...Love ya too" you said despite the fact you were all alone now. That was the first time a boy had ever told you that he loved you. Feeling happy and contented to drifted off to sleep.

As you woke the next morning, you felt awfully lonely without Jeff around you. You were used to him being around and he was the reason for your smile for almost all of the the time. You were sure this day would be boring so you decided to go the cemetery today. It has been approximately two weeks now since your mother's death and it would be a good idea to buy new flowers for her. You dressed yourself up and left your apartment. You went to the flower shop to buy flowers and headed to the cemetery afterwards. As you stood at her grave, many questions filled your mind. Was she really an entity, like your dad had said? Do entities really die? Was she watching over you? What was her opinion about everything you had done? Was she happy you killed dad and found your first love that was a serial killer? Or was she utterly horrified at how her daughter's innocence had gone so fast?

 These were all questions that would not be answered but nevertheless you felt... happy. You still missed your mother, but you were a lot happier than the previous week.

Evening came and you decided to go home. As you finally reached your apartment, you were reminded of your loneliness. You were used to being alone since you were a kid because you weren't allowed to have friends but right now... the loneliness was dragging you down. You really wished Jeff would appear and maybe you could make love again or something... Or maybe he would drag you along in a killing spree of his. Would he appear here again tonight? You really hoped so.

With nothing else to do, you decided to sit in your sofa and watch some TV.

Hours passed and all of a sudden your doorbell rang. Was it Jeff? No way, he would never in his entire existence ring the doorbell. That didn't suit him at all. But if it wasn't him, who could be visiting you this late? You got up to see who it was.

As you opened the door, your heart froze.

"(n), it is? You are under arrest!"

Three cops were standing at your doorway and you recognized them immediately: they were the cops that were surveying your school.

Two of them grabbed hold of you, while the middle one handcuffed you.

"You're coming with us. We've got questions."

Jeff's POV

Freaking Slenderman, he keeps worrying about nothing! I am a feared killer, beautiful and immortal; what could possibly happen to me? And screw Masky and Hoody for disturbing me and (n), we were having such a good time! I wanted to be with her again. I sped up my pace towards her apartment. I couldn't wait to see my precious killer baby again.

But as I got there I saw a police car parked right in front of the building. I froze in place. No way. No fucking way.

I snuck closer to the two policemen to gather more information.

"... can't believe such a young girl would do those things with Jeff the Killer..." One of the cops said.

"I just hope the guys at the police station find out more about him."

Fuck! I knew it wasn't a good idea to leave (n) alone there! I should have taken her with me! God, how could I be this stupid?? Fuck Masky and Hoody for distracting me! Fuck them all!

I really wanted to gut these two policemen but there was something more important right now. I couldn't waste any more time. She was taken to the police station? Then I have to hurry to get there. They better not try to hurt her.

I ran as fast as I could. I had to get her out of there.