BILLY
"Are plans are changing," I said to Stu. I couldn't go along with the plan to attack Sidney tonight, not with Y/N being there. I wouldn't do it again. I couldn't do not again. We weren't planning on killing her tonight, just scaring her. But I still couldn't do that. We scared Y/N enough yesterday night and I had to force myself to hurt her. It was hard to even look at her without seeing the terror in her E/C eyes. Without seeing my hand guide my knife into her stomach.
"We aren't going to attack Sid?" Stu asked as we drove down the road. "No. I can't do it. Not with my sister being there. We put her through enough yesterday night. But there is someone else we can kill," I said. He looked over at me, eyebrows raised and amusement in his eyes. "Jason?" He asked. We both hated that asshole. Y/N was just as much Stu's little sister as she was mine. I didn't question the relationship at first but as it went on I noticed little things. I noticed him falling in love with her and I noticed her slowly pulling away. Y/N liked Randy. She's liked him for a while now and I knew she was only with Jason to try and get rid of those feelings. But it wasn't working and she was pulling away.
The night he told her his feelings and she turned him down I was standing in the kitchen watching them from the window. And as soon as his hands were on her I was out the door in seconds. The next day I told Stu about what happened. It took both of us threatening him for him to finally back off but it seemed he was back at it. "No. Not yet. But don't worry his day is coming. No. Tonight we go after Nate. I've seen the way he looks at Y/N," I said.
Stu nodded his head, his hand gripping the wheel tighter. "Yeah, so have I. He looks at her like he's undressing her. I'm sure Jason bragged about what he's done to her," he said. As much as Y/N tried hiding it, I knew he let Jason take her virginity. We normally tell each other things but she knew if she told me what happened I would have ripped his head off for touching her.
It's not that I don't trust her because I do. She's super smart. So smart that she skipped seventh grade. At first I hated having my little sister in the same grade but then I was grateful that she was. I didn't have to worry about her being in a separate school for a year and I wouldn't have to worry about graduating and leaving her behind. "Yeah, I know. When Tatum brought him up, I wanted to go find him and kill him right there." Tonight he will die. I would kill him and gut him. He would never look at my sister again.
Y/N
The bus stopped in front of Sidney's house and we got off saying goodbye to our friends. Sidney checked her mailbox before we headed inside. When we were inside we set our bags down and walked into the kitchen. Sidney got us drinks and a snack. We talked about school and what we would do tonight at Tatum's as we did our homework. Then Sid went up to her room and grabbed a change of clothes.
We were sitting on the couches in the sitting room, Sidney flipping through channels. The only thing that was on was the news. They all talked about Casey and Steve being murders and me being the lone survivor. Then Sidney's mom popped up on the screen. She stared at the screen for a minute before she turned the tv off. "Are you okay?" I asked. She had her head down as she played with her fingers. She nodded her head as an answer then looked up at me.
"Can I ask you something?" She asked. We stood up and walked to the living room and sat on the green couch. "Yeah," I said as I grabbed a pillow to sit in my lap. "It's about what happened," she said, twisting to look at me. "Yeah, it's fine," I said. "Did they suffer? Like was I quick?" She asked. I knew she was asking only because her mom was killed in a similar way. She came home to find her upstairs in the bedroom. Blood splattered on the walls, curling, soaking the sheets and mattress.
"Umm. Steve's was quick. The killer wanted to play a game with us. It was movie trivia. He started out with a warm up question. What is the name of the killer in Halloween? It was easy and I got it right. But the real question was for Casey since Steve was her boyfriend," I said. "What was the question?" Sidney asked.
"Who's the killer in Friday the 13th?" I said, looking out the window. "Casey jumped the gun. She jumped up yelling at Jason but that was the wrong answer. Mrs. Voorhees was the killer, not Jason. Jason didn't come in until the sequel. So he killed Steve. He--he was duct taped to one of the deck chairs. The killer just came up and--" I trailed off. I cleared my throat before saying, "Then he threw a chair through the patio doors. Me and Casey were able to get out but when we were going past the kitchen windows he was at one of them and just busted through it. I told her to run then I punched him and ran after her.
"I got caught up with Steve though. I couldn't stop looking at him until I heard the pounding of boots. I ran around the corner of the house to the side and Casey ran around to the front. Before I could go after her the killer fucking jumped through the window and tackled me. I heard Casey scream but couldn't get to her. I think there was more than one killer," I said. Sidney was about to say something but the phone rang. I jumped at the sound and she picked it up. "Hello?"
"Okay. Hold on. It's Tatum, she's running late. She wants to know if you want her to pick up a movie," said. I rolled my eyes and laughed. "She wants that movie with Tom Cruise in it "All the Right Moves". Because as she claims" If you pause it just right you can see his penis," I said. I said it loud enough that Tatum heard it and laughed. Sidney hung up and continued talking. Tatum didn't show up until almost eight. She said practice ran late.