Unexpected~A Markiplier x Reader Fanfic

Note: y/f/c=your favorite coffee

You watched as he went to his house, right next to yours. You were suddenly asking a thousand questions. 'See ya around? What does that mean? Does he not think I'm too weird? Should I try to visit him soon? Should I have told him my name?'

You continued to unpack for the rest of the day while you wondered what to do with this new neighbor. After a few hours, you had gotten most everything settled in. Right before you went to bed, you smiled to yourself. 'Markiplier is my neighbor, and I may have even made a good first impression?' You then climbed into bed, and you fell asleep the instant your head hit the pillow.

You stayed in your house for several days, too nervous to see Mark again. After a while, you gave up and decided to go get some coffee at this really good coffee shop you heard of. 'What  was that place called again? Oh yeah, Great Brews.'  You quietly snuck out to your car and drove to Great Brews, which was just a few minutes away. You made your way in and ordered y/f/c. Once you got it and turned around to find a table, you saw none other than Mark. He waved you over, and your legs started to feel like jelly as you wobbled over.

"Hey, long time time no see!" He said as you sat down next to him.

"What's up?" You said casually. 'Just be cool, don't be weird!' you told yourself.

"Nothing much. I actually would like to apologize."

"Oh?"

"Yeah," he went on, "at our last encounter, I never asked you about your name. I'm sorry, I shouldn't have left that quickly. Care to fill me in on that?"

"Oh that's alright," you giggled, "My name's (y/n)."

"'(y/n)'. I like it!" he declared with a big grin.

"Thanks," you said blushing, "I like your name too. It, uh, suits you well." 'Nice going there, Captain Smooth!' you thought to yourself.

He giggled and thanked you as he stirred his drink. You had just noticed the drink he was holding and laughed, "Is that a caramel frappuccino? Mark, you're so basic!"

"Shut up!" he laughed clutching his drink, "It's my favorite!" You smiled to yourself. You were starting to become more comfortable with him. You both talked for a couple more hours, while purchasing a couple more drinks and some muffins. The conversation started normal, but as the chat went on, the topics got weirder.

"You have 抖阴社区?!" You exclaimed.

"Maybe...the stories on there are really good!" He tried to defend himself.

"Do you read any fanfics about yourself?" You said, raising your eyebrows suggestively.

"No, I mostly read the science fiction stories on there. Don't judge me!" He pouted as you laughed. You felt like you could talk to him about anything!

After three drinks and four muffins, you both decided to head home. You followed his car back to your neighborhood. After you got out of the car and waved goodbye, he shouted, "Wait!", scribbled something on a paper, and ran over to you.

"Here's my number," he handed the paper to you, "just so you can warn me when you're about to bug me at Great Brews," he joked.

"Gimme your phone," you retorted, "I'll put my number in so you can warn me when you're there and I can decide to just have coffee at home."

He smirked as you handed him his phone back, "thanks. See ya later, (y/n)." You could swear you could see him blushing, just a little bit.

You waved to him as he turned back to his house. You smiled to yourself, looking at his phone number in your hand. You decided you were definitely going to get coffee at that place again.