FallOutBoy Preferences? [?,?]

Patrick;
    Patrick isn't a big fan of scary movies, but decided to watch one with you just so you'd have company. "Are you sure you want to watch this? This movie is pretty scary and gross.." you ask Patrick before starting the movie. Patrick sighs. "Yes. Of course I do. I can handle it no problem.." you shrug. "Alright, I warned you though.." throughout the movie you were completely fine, not even batting an eye at the jumpscares and brutal killing scenes, as for Patrick, he was quivering in the corner of the couch gripping his shirt. Once you finally took notice of Patrick's fear, you paused the movie and turned towards him. He looks as you, "I can't handle it just hold me.."

Joe;
   You've never seen Joe scared, and by never you mean never. And if he were to get scared it'd be once in a blue moon, and you wouldn't be around to see it. One night you had a plan, you asked Joe what scares him the most. Spiders. Of course he'd choose spiders. While he was out with Andy doing some stupid shit, you went to the gift shop around the corner from your apartment. You bought a rubber spider, bigger than your own hand. Once back home, you placed it in the closet where Joe usually hangs his coat. Smiling devilishly, you closed the closet running into the bedroom. Joe finally arrived home, making his presence known. You peek your head out the bedroom door and watch him open the closet door. "What did you do all dAYYY" he jumps back away from the closet with the rubber spider hitting the floor in front of him. You fall over laughing, him giving you the silent treatment for a solid two days.

Andy;
    Andy gets scared easily unlike Pete or Joe. Since Andy is so easy to scare, you like to fuck with him. You just find it cute when he gets scared which is why you always prank him. But one stormy night, you might've taken it a bit too far. While Andy was asleep on the couch, you came up with a plan to scare him. Forgetting that he gets scared easily, you decided to go big. So you turned out every light in the house and wore all black so he wouldn't see you pretend to be a poltergeist (or some shit like that)
You started off by creating a loud bang which woke him up immediately. He stood up and walked towards the sound, not thinking to turn the lights on because he assumed the power flicked off due to the storm. When he saw nothing, he turned around and started to call your name. You tip toe up behind him and whisper. "y/n isn't here anymore~" he screams, turns around, and hits your dead in the jaw, knocking you out on impact. Andy freaks out the turns the lights on, seeing blood run down your chin, he picks you up, taking you to the emergency room.

Pete;
    Pete's a stone cold rock. Won't get scared for anything. You brush that thought off as you set up a scene in which you were technically drowning. You and Pete were relaxing at the community pool, him out to get some nachos and you staying behind. You laid face first into the water, taking in as much air as needed for this to work. He finally comes back and you're almost out of air. He just stands there. "Come on y/n, I know this is a prank.." wanting to stay committed to this prank, you stay, face in water, despite the lack of oxygen. When you still didn't move, Pete gets nervous. "Come on y/n stop playing around.." just as you were thinking it was time to get up, you lose consciousness, it's the real deal now. Pete starts to scream your name and soon jump in after you, laying you on the concrete and giving you mouth to mouth. Once you finally regained consciousness, you looked up at Pete with a weak smile. "Gotcha."