"Tiffany, can you please explain to us why you've been messing around with all of us?" She exhales deeply and tries to come up with an answer, but she was just as confused at the boys were. "I- I don't know..." They all sigh. "Can you all tell me why you had to hide me from each other?" She says somewhat annoyed that they'd come harass her for their wrong doings as well. "What?" She folds her arms and looks at each of their faces. "Come inside, we can talk in my room." They walk into the house and up to the girls room, saying hello to Rachel along the way. She walks in with Tiffany and they all sit, Tiffany's arms fold again. "Why did you all hide me from each other?" She speaks somewhat angrily as she's been awaiting an answer to this very question. "How do you know that—" "Just answer the question, please." They all look down at their feet and hands, trying to avoid answering the question because they all know they have the same exact answer. "I'm waiting for an answer." Tiffany says sternly. "I wanted you to myself." Mattia finally answers, the boys nod their heads agreeing that they wanted the same thing as well. "So then why couldn't you just tell the others to back off instead of giving me different names? Shania? Abigail? Analicia? Really?" She was frustrated with them, but more with herself for even doing what she did, she's not the type to mess with multiple people at one time.
"Ok but let's talk about you now, why did you do all the things you did with us? Just for fun or your own amusement?" Kairi's short self stands and taps his foot anxiously against the ground as he speaks. "I truly don't know what I was thinking, much like you guys, I didn't think you would all find out about each other." They look at each other and shake their heads, they understand where she's coming from because they had the same mindset. "Can I be honest?" Alejandro asks shyly as everyone focuses on him, they nod their heads. "I understand where you're coming from because I felt the same way, about you guys not finding out about the real her that is." He looks at her with pain stricken eyes as Mattia clears his throat. "Actually same, I wanted to keep it hidden from you guys for as long as possible. I'm sorry." "Me too, I'm so sorry you guys had to find out this way." Tiffany says as she rests her cheek against her knee, Rachel rubs her sisters back gently. "I'm sorry as well." Kairi begins while slumping back down on Tiffany's bed. "This is just a very shitty situation now huh?"
He laughs nervously trying to lighten everyones mood, but the moment turns sour as a question pops into Mattia's mind. "Who do you like more?" His question catches Tiffany off guard, she corrects her posture and looks into his eyes. "What?" "I said who do you like more? Out of the three of us, which would you choose?" She shakes her head, she can't believe he's asking her to pick out of the three of them. "I kinda wanna know that too." Kairi says as he scratches the back of his neck. "Yeah same." Alejandro adds as the three of them look directly at her, each one hoping she'd say their name. "Look guys, I don't want to be pressured into choosing someone." She says nervously. "We understand that a hundred percent, we're just curious, that's all." Mattia justifies himself but Tiffany isn't buying it. "I don't know, I don't want to hurt anyone's feelings."
The boys study her body language and can tell that she's feeing uncomfortable. "Ok, I have a proposal." Alejandro says as a brilliant idea pops into his head. "If you're up to it of course, each of us can take you on two dates and whoever wins you over the most gets to keep going out with you." That didn't sound like a bad plan, and at least it came from the most level headed of the trio. "Any rules?" Tiffany asks whilst biting the inside of her cheek. "None." Mattia says as a small grin appears on his face, Tiffany purses her lips and nods her head slightly. "Done deal." She shakes each of their hands and sends them on their way back to Mattia's house. They all have the exact same brilliant ideas flowing through their minds, how can they sabotage the others dates with the girl?
𝗔𝘂𝘁𝗵𝗼𝗿𝘀 𝗡𝗼𝘁𝗲:
Ok hi, I haven't really put any notes in this story so I figured I'd put one here. This story is lowkey confusing if you think about it from a standpoint that isn't like a 'free spirit' or a high school 'hoe.'
This chapter somewhat answers the question of 'how did they not know all along?' The short answer is because boys are dumb, the long answer is because boys are actually sneaky like this with girls in high school, in this case it's just that the roles are reversed making the girl the sneaky one.
I really hope you're liking this story so far, I've been trying to make it interesting and like eventful, especially with the date *wink* (the dates really plays through nicely with the rest of this act so teehee prepare yourself for that👀)
Also thank you sm for the feedback, I love seeing comments and stuff from like alejandrosdimple and mevainlove lmao they're so funny😂 and ofc I love seeing comments from other people, but they're the ones that comment the most 🤷🏼♀️ BUT N E WAYS, ily and tysm for reading this ahaha🧚♀️💞✨
