Stefan: He'd be the big spoon, his free hand playing with your hair.
Damon: He'd want to be as close as possible- holding each other, legs entwined, etc.
Jeremy: I feel like he would either be in a protective position or a submissive position, just depending on how he feels. At the end of the day, the only thing that really matters to him is that he has you.
Silas: He's probably laying on his back and pulling you close with one arm around you, the other holding your hand across his stomach.
Enzo: Like I said, he's the little spoon but shhhh don't tell anyone.
Elijah: You two would be laying facing each other with your hands joined in between you.
Klaus: He'd be laying his head on your chest while you play with his hair.
Rebekah: She'd have her chin on the top of your head while she cradled you.
Kol: He'd want your head on his chest as he strokes your back.
Kai: Like Enzo, he wants to feel cared for, but he'd want to be facing you and holding onto you.
Katherine: She'd lie on her back while you lay your head on her arm that's playing with her hair.
Marcel: He'd want you laying right on top of him so he could bear hug cuddle you.
Elena: She'd lay her head on your chest, delicately holding your waist.
Bonnie: You'd both be laying side by side with your arms wrapped around each other.
Caroline: You two would take turns being the little spoon, but she likes being the big spoon a little better because that way she can put her chin on your shoulder
Hayley: She wants your head on her chest, with her arms wrapped around you while she kisses your hair.
A/N: I feel like I should be using GIFs for this but I feel like writing it out captures the detail better. Also I'm too lazy to go out and search for them lol.