Beta Squad Advent Calendar 2024

Prompt fill: Naughty or Nice
romantic pairing
AJ x Niko
Smut

"Aj," Niko's voice was full of laughter, matching the mood of the video they were filming at the moment.

The lie detector game was called naughty or nice, basically just another of never have I ever. Niko, Aj, and James were greatly amusing themselves, posing more and more inappropriate questions.

"See, now I know you're lying, brother." James shook his head and pointed at Aj with the cards in his hand.

"How would you even know if Aj had some unscheduled fun in a room where anyone could have walked in, James?" Niko grinned maniacally, then held his hands up when James glared at him.

"I cordially invite you to remember last Tuesday then, Nikolas," James said meaningfully. Aj frowned and mouthed "last Tuesday" before his eyes widened and he caught Niko's gaze.

Together, they broke out laughing, while James shook his head miserably.

Last Tuesday

Aj had his arms laying crossed on the kitchen island, head pillowed on top. He was panting, bent over, and pushing his hips back against Niko's thrusts. 

Niko groaned behind him, snapping his hips faster and grinding deeply on every second push.

His hands left lilac imprints on Aj's waist, marking him clearly as his. Pleased, Niko dragged one hand up Aj's clothed back, burying it in his hair and wrenching his head up and back.

His boyfriend's back arched to accommodate the new position, and it left Aj's throat perfectly exposed for Niko to suck a hickey into the sensitive flesh there.

"Niko, please," Aj moaned. His boyfriend grinned wolfishly, face hidden against Aj's collarbone. "Yeah, baby," he went harder, readjusting his angle until Aj was moaning uncontrollably, letting out breathy uh, uh, uh's in quick succession.

"I got you." Fuck, Niko was close. He just needed -

Suddenly, a high-pitched scream interrupted the heated atmosphere. In the doorway with a pale face, wide eyes, and an open mouth staring in horror was James.

Niko and Aj froze for a second.

Then Aj's brain seemed to catch up to the fact that Niko's dick wasn't moving but instead pressing right into his prostate. With a suppressed moan, Aj clenched around Niko, causing him to tighten his grip on Aj's waist while his hips jerked.

Niko looked down to where they were connected, up at an ashen-faced James, and down again. He squeezed Aj's waist, getting a shrug and an impatient wiggle back in return.

Well, then.

Without breaking eye contact with James, Niko drew his hips back. James breathed out an "oh no," but Aj's mouth had already fallen open involuntary at the movement, and when Niko pushed back in, a broken sob bullied its way out of his throat.

James went beet red, turned on his heels, and hightailed it out of the kitchen.

[At the shoot, Aj winked at James and mumbled under his breath, "wasn't like you couldn't have joined us," before Niko and him broke out giggling again at James alarmed look towards their camera man.]

[This prompt literally required smut, I refuse to take criticism for that]