Until dawn (reader insert)

(If kiara is alive)
Mike was explaining how he found so many clues at the sanitorium. You looked at Kiara who seemed to be worried about Josh, hoping he was still alive.

You hugged her as the three of you approached a lake (imma just call it that) and jumped in but the water was freezing cold as you made your way quickly to the other side as to not freeze to death.

Once you got to the other side, you found Hannah's diary and realized that she dug up Beth and became a wendigo. Kiara couldn't believe that her  best friend had been alive this whole time and she didn't even know it, despite how many times shes been to this mine.

You tried to comfort Kiara and the four of you heard what seemed to be Josh screaming "no you're not real!" Kiara gasped and quickly ran over to open a door only for water to splash out revealing her father's body just hanging there.

Kiara fell to her knees and began to cry, "dad..." You heard her say and felt really horrible for her. "Why did you leave me?... It was bad enough mom left....you were the only family i had left..." Mike and Sam exchanged glances at this point, now knowing how much she lost.

You patted kiara's back before the four of you walked up to Josh to see him hallucinating. "Josh!" You said trying to get him to snap out of it but he couldn't hear you.  Mike slapped and Kiara snapped at him.

"M-mike..  Plz don't h-hit m-me" Josh said and he looked at Kiara, kissing her deeply which shocked you all. You then smiled 'good job Josh' you thought and mike aplogized for what he did to Josh.

After pushing Sam up the ledge, you, Kiara, Mike, and Josh began walking back the way you came, Josh still still slightly talking to himself while holding Kiara's hand.

You and Mike were walking when you were pulled under water and quickly hid behind a rock but watched as the wendigo approached Kiara and Josh.

Kiara stood in front of Josh and noticed the butterfly tattoo on the wendigo's arm as did Josh "HANNAH?!?!" they both said in unison as Hannah looked at them before grabbing them both and dragging them away as they screamed.

You tried to go after them but Mike stopped you "no they're gone y/n we have to go"

(If Kiara is dead)
You continue to walk on as Mike explains the things he found at the sanitorium. You ignored Mike the whole way and crossed the lake quickly as to not freeze your ass off.

Once on the other side, you noticed a diary and began to read it, realizing that Hannah had been here for so long that she ended up digging up Beth and becoming a wendigo.

You sighed sadly, imagining the look on Kiara's face before you heard someone scream "no you're not real!" 'Josh?' You thought as the three of you rushed towards a door and opened it only for water to splash out at you.

You looked up and saw the flamethrower guys and Kiara's body just hanging there and you began to cry as Mike and Sam couldn't believe what they just saw (and btw their heads are missing since they were both ripped off). You got up and went to Josh.

"Josh!!" You said and tried to snap him back into reality but nothing was working. Mike slapped Josh and it seemed to work but you were a little pissed at him for that. "M-m-mike don't hit me p-plz" Josh stuttered.

You noticed Josh looking around as if searching for someone and you began to shake before he looked at you "w-w-where's kiara?" He asked while Mike was helping Sam up onto the ledge.

"You better see for yourself..." You said and lead him into the place with the bodies and watched as Josh fell to his knees "no... No plz no... Not kiara..." He said to himself mumbling a few things.

"Josh... I'm so sorry.... I.. I thought i heard your voice when we went to warn Mike about some wendigos, so i followed it and K-Kiara saved my life..." You explained and he looked at you with hatred in his eyes.

Mike caught up with you two and told Josh about Hannah being in the mines before the three of you walked back the way you came from, Josh never even once looking at you or talking to you. Suddenly you and mike were pulled under water and hid behind a rock.

You watched as a wendigo picked up Josh and he saw the butterfly tattoo on its shoulder. "Hannah?" He asked and the wendigo seemed to recongnize him and dragged him away.

You and mike were scared as hell and quickly began to run back to the lodge, hoping everyone else was alright.